It was late in November, and Holmes and I sat on either side of a bright fire in our Baker Street sitting room while thick fog pressed against the windows outside. Since returning from Devon, Holmes had been busy with two very important cases, both ending in complete success, so he was in excellent spirits. That very afternoon Sir Henry and Dr. Mortimer had stopped by to say goodbye before setting out on the long sea voyage doctors had recommended for Sir Henry's recovery. Naturally their visit turned our conversation back to the Baskerville mystery. I had waited patiently for this chance, knowing Holmes never liked mixing past work with a case still on his desk, and now I asked him to walk me through the whole affair from beginning to end.
"From the point of view of the man who called himself Stapleton, the whole plan was simple and direct," said Holmes, leaning back in his chair. "To us, of course, who didn't know his motives at first and only saw scattered pieces of the truth, it seemed completely baffling. I have had two long talks with Mrs. Stapleton since that night, and I don't think a single secret remains hidden now."
"Would you mind going through the story from memory for me?" I asked.
"Gladly, though I can't promise to remember every tiny detail. Hard concentration has a way of wiping older cases clean from my mind—new problems push out old ones, just as my last two cases have already blurred my memory of Baskerville Hall. Still, I will give you the main steps as clearly as I can, and you can remind me if I leave anything out.
"My inquiries proved beyond any doubt that the family portrait told the truth: Stapleton really was a Baskerville. He was the son of Sir Charles's youngest brother, Rodger Baskerville, who fled in disgrace to Central America and was thought to have died there unmarried. In reality, Rodger did marry and had one son, who carried his father's name—Rodger Baskerville.
"This younger Rodger grew up and married Beryl Garcia, a young beauty from Costa Rica. After stealing a large sum of public money, he changed his name to Vandeleur and escaped to England, where he opened a private school in eastern Yorkshire. He had met a sick tutor named Fraser on the ship home and used the man's teaching talent to build up the school. When Fraser died, however, the school lost its good name and ended in disgrace. Changing his name once more to Stapleton, he moved to the south of England with what money he had left, his schemes for the future, and his genuine love of studying insects. I checked at the British Museum and learned that Vandeleur was a respected expert in that field—a moth he first described in Yorkshire is still named after him.
"That brings us to his arrival in Devon. He had clearly looked into the family history and learned that only two lives stood between him and a wealthy estate. His exact plans were probably vague at first, yet he meant trouble from the start—that is obvious from the way he introduced his wife as his sister, already planning to use her as a decoy if needed. First he settled as close to his family home as he could, and then he made friends with Sir Charles and the neighbors.
"Sir Charles himself told Stapleton the legend of the hound, preparing the way for his own murder. From Dr. Mortimer, Stapleton also learned that the old man's heart was weak and that a sudden shock could kill him, especially since Sir Charles took the family curse seriously. That clever, cruel mind saw at once how Sir Charles might be killed in a way that could never be proved against the real killer.
"An ordinary plotter would have been satisfied with a fierce dog, yet Stapleton went further by turning the beast into a glowing monster. He bought the largest, fiercest dog he could find from a dealer in Fulham Road in London, brought it down by the North Devon train, and walked far across the moor in secret to bring it home unnoticed. Already, while hunting butterflies and beetles, he had learned the safe paths across the great Grimpen Mire, so he hid the hound at the old mine and waited for his chance.
"His chance took a long time coming. Sir Charles never went out onto the moor at night. Several times Stapleton waited in the dark with the hound to no effect—and those were the nights when country people caught sight of the glowing beast and confirmed the old ghost stories. Stapleton had hoped his wife would draw Sir Charles into a romance to lure him outside, yet here she stood unexpectedly firm. Neither threats nor even beatings could make her play that part, and for a while Stapleton was stuck.
"Luck opened the door when Sir Charles, trusting Stapleton as a friend, asked him to deliver charity money to poor Mrs. Laura Lyons. Pretending to be an unmarried man, Stapleton quickly gained complete control over her by promising to marry her once she divorced her husband. Suddenly he learned Sir Charles was leaving for London on Dr. Mortimer's advice—advice Stapleton pretended to support. He had to act at once before his victim slipped away. So he forced Mrs. Lyons to write the letter begging Sir Charles to meet her on his last night at the Hall, then talked her out of going.
"Driving back from Coombe Tracey that evening, he had plenty of time to fetch the hound, paint it with his glowing paste, and bring it to the moor gate where Sir Charles was waiting. Urged on by its master, the beast leaped over the low gate and chased the poor old man down the yew alley. What a sight that must have been in the dark tunnel—that huge black shape with flaming jaws bounding behind him until his weak heart gave out and he fell dead! And notice why no animal tracks showed along the alley: while Sir Charles ran down the gravel path, the hound kept to the grass strip beside it, stepping onto the path only near the body to sniff at him before turning back. Those footprints were the ones Dr. Mortimer noticed. Stapleton called the hound off and hurried back to the mire, leaving behind a mystery that baffled everyone.
"Both women had strong reasons to suspect him afterward. Mrs. Stapleton already knew about the hound and his plans against Sir Charles; Mrs. Lyons noticed that Sir Charles died at the exact time of a secret meeting known only to Stapleton. Yet both were firmly under his thumb, and neither dared speak.
"Probably Stapleton didn't even know about the heir in Canada until Dr. Mortimer kindly told him all the details of Sir Henry's arrival. His first thought was to kill Sir Henry in London before he ever reached Devon. Because his wife had refused to trap Sir Charles, Stapleton no longer trusted her out of his sight, so he brought her to London and kept her locked inside her room at the Mexborough Private Hotel in Craven Street—actually one of the very hotels Cartwright checked later. While Stapleton wore a false beard and shadowed Dr. Mortimer from Baker Street to Waterloo Station and the Northumberland Hotel, his wife guessed his wicked plan. Too afraid of his violence to write a normal letter—for he might have killed her if he had found it—she cut printed words out of the *Times* and disguised her writing on the envelope to warn Sir Henry of his danger.
"Stapleton also needed something worn by Sir Henry so the hound could follow his scent if needed. He clearly bribed a servant at the hotel to steal a boot. By pure chance, the first boot stolen was brand new and useless for a dog's nose, so he had it slipped back and took an old one instead. That strange incident told me at once that we were dealing with a real hound—nothing else could explain why a thief cared so much about getting a worn boot rather than a new one.
"Looking at how calmly he followed our friends in the cab, and how much he knew about my appearance and our rooms in Baker Street, I suspect his career of crime began long before the Baskerville plot. Over the past three years, there have been four major burglaries in the west of England where no thief was ever caught. During the last one, at Folkestone Court in May, a masked burglar shot a young servant boy who surprised him. I have little doubt Stapleton paid his bills that way and has been a ruthless criminal for years. After boldly sending my own name back to me through the cab driver, he realized London was no longer safe for him, returned straight to Dartmoor, and waited for Sir Henry there."
"Wait one moment," I said. "You have explained almost everything clearly, yet one point still puzzles me. Who fed and cared for the hound while Stapleton was away in London?"
"I looked into that carefully," Holmes replied. "Stapleton had a helper, though he probably didn't share all his secrets with him. Do you remember the frail old manservant we met in the hallway at Merripit House? His name was Anthony, and I learned he had been with the Stapletons for years, as far back as the school in Yorkshire, so he must have known they were husband and wife. He has now vanished and left England. Anthony is not a common English name, whereas Antonio is very common in Central America and other Spanish-speaking countries. Like Mrs. Stapleton, the old man spoke good English, yet with a slight lisp—he probably came from Central America too. I saw him myself once crossing the mire along the marked path. Almost certainly he cared for the hound while his master was away, even if he never knew what evil purpose it served.
"As for my own part," Holmes continued, "when I examined that cut-and-pasted warning letter that morning in Baker Street, I didn't hold it near my face only to check the paper. I noticed a faint trace of perfume: white jasmine. There are seventy-five different scents every crime expert ought to recognize, and more than one case has turned on spotting them. A woman's perfume pointed my thoughts straight toward the Stapletons. So before I ever left London, I already knew there was a real hound and suspected our naturalist.
"To watch Stapleton properly, I had to hide my presence, since he would have been far too cautious if I stayed openly at the Hall. So I deceived everyone—even you, Watson—and came down to Devon in secret. My life wasn't nearly as uncomfortable as you imagined when you found my stone hut! Most of the time I stayed in Coombe Tracey and only moved out onto the moor when I needed to be close to Merripit House. Cartwright came down with me, dressed like a local country boy, brought me food and clean clothes, and often watched you while I watched Stapleton. Your letters reached me quickly from Baker Street and helped enormously—especially that detail about Stapleton once running a school in the north, which let me trace Vandeleur's past. You also cleared up the whole mystery of the escaped convict and the Barrymores, though I had already guessed most of that myself.
"By the night we met on the moor, I knew the whole truth, yet I still lacked proof that would stand up in court. Even Selden's tragic death couldn't prove Stapleton had tried to murder Sir Henry. We had no choice except to catch him red-handed—and to do that, we had to use Sir Henry alone as bait. I blame myself for exposing our client to such horror, though I couldn't foresee either the thick fog or the terrifying glow of that half-starved beast. Still, both Dr. Mortimer and the London specialist assure me the shock will pass completely during his voyage. What hurt Sir Henry worst of all was learning that the woman he deeply loved had deceived him.
"Now let me tell you her side, which makes the whole tragedy clearer. Stapleton held immense power over his wife—through love, through fear, or perhaps both together. At his command she agreed to pretend she was his sister, though she refused to help him commit murder. Instead, she tried again and again to warn Sir Henry without directly giving her husband away. Stapleton himself seems to have been fiercely jealous; even though encouraging Sir Henry's visits was part of his own trap, he couldn't stop himself from flying into a rage when he saw Sir Henry hold her.
"On the last day, however, everything changed. She had learned enough about Selden's death to suspect the truth, and she knew the hound was locked in the garden shed just before Sir Henry came to dinner. She confronted her husband angrily, and in the bitter quarrel that followed, he let slip for the first time that another woman waited for him. In a single moment, all her loyalty turned to hatred. Seeing that she would betray him, Stapleton beat her and tied her up so she could not warn Sir Henry. He hoped, no doubt, that once Sir Henry died and everyone blamed the Baskerville curse, he could win her forgiveness and keep her silent. I think he badly misjudged her anger; even if we hadn't arrived that night, she would have brought him down. And there, my dear Watson, without opening my notebooks, is the whole story."
"He couldn't have expected to frighten young Sir Henry to death the way he scared old Sir Charles," I remarked.
"The hound was half-starved and savage," Holmes answered. "Even if shock didn't stop Sir Henry's heart, it would freeze him long enough to keep him from fighting back."
"There is only one puzzle left," I said. "If Stapleton had succeeded and become the last heir, how could he ever have explained living secretly right beside the estate under a false name? Wouldn't claiming the fortune have brought suspicion down on him at once?"
"That was indeed a difficult problem, Watson, and Mrs. Stapleton told me she heard her husband talk it over several times. He had three possible plans. He could claim the estate from Central America, proving who he was before British officials there without ever returning to England. Or he could wear a clever disguise for the short time he needed to appear in London. Or he could give the proof and family papers to a partner, letting that man step forward as the heir in exchange for a share of the income. Knowing Stapleton, I don't doubt he would have found some clever way around it.
"And now, my dear Watson, we have done more than enough hard work these past weeks. For one evening, let us put dark plots out of our minds. I have a box at the opera tonight for *Les Huguenots*. If you can be ready in half an hour, we can stop at Marcini's for a good dinner on the way."