Our breakfast table was cleared early, and Holmes sat waiting in his dressing gown for our ten o'clock appointment. Our guests arrived right on time. Just as the clock struck ten, Dr. Mortimer was shown upstairs, followed closely by Sir Henry Baskerville.
Sir Henry was a short, strongly built man of about thirty, with dark eyes, thick black eyebrows, and a firm, determined face. He wore a reddish-brown tweed suit and had the weather-beaten skin of someone who had spent years in the open air. At the same time, his steady gaze and calm manner showed a quiet confidence.
"This is Sir Henry Baskerville," said Dr. Mortimer.
"Yes, indeed," said Sir Henry. "And the odd thing, Mr. Sherlock Holmes, is that even if my friend hadn't suggested coming here this morning, I would have come on my own. I hear you're good at solving little puzzles, and I received one this morning that takes more thinking than I can manage."
"Please sit down, Sir Henry. Do you mean you have already had some strange experience since arriving in London?"
"Nothing very big, Mr. Holmes—just someone's idea of a joke, most likely. It was this letter, if you can call it a letter, that came for me this morning."
He laid an envelope on the table, and we all leaned over to look at it. It was made of cheap gray paper. The address—"Sir Henry Baskerville, Northumberland Hotel"—was written by hand in rough block letters. The postmark read "Charing Cross," dated the evening before.
"Who knew you were going to the Northumberland Hotel?" asked Holmes, looking sharply across at our visitor.
"Nobody could have known. We only chose it after I met Dr. Mortimer."
"But perhaps Dr. Mortimer was already staying there?"
"No, I was staying with a friend," said the doctor. "There was no way anyone could have known we planned to go to that hotel."
"Hmm! Someone seems to take a very close interest in your movements."
Out of the envelope Holmes drew a half-sheet of plain white paper folded in four. He opened it and smoothed it flat on the table. Across the middle, a single line had been put together by gluing printed words onto the sheet:
As you value your life or your reason keep away from the moor.
Only the word "moor" was written by hand in ink.
"Now," said Sir Henry, "perhaps you can tell me, Mr. Holmes, what on earth that means, and who cares so much about my business?"
"What do you make of it, Dr. Mortimer?" asked Holmes. "You must admit there is nothing supernatural about this, at least."
"No, sir, though it could easily come from someone who believes the whole business is supernatural."
"What business?" Sir Henry cut in sharply. "It seems to me that you gentlemen know a great deal more about my affairs than I do."
"You will know everything we know before you leave this room, Sir Henry. I promise you that," said Holmes. "For now, if you don't mind, let's look closely at this very interesting paper, which must have been put together and mailed yesterday evening. Do you have yesterday's *Times*, Watson?"
"It is over there in the corner."
"Would you hand it to me—the inside sheet, please, with the opinion articles?"
Holmes ran his eyes quickly up and down the columns. "An excellent article here on free trade. Let me read you a sentence from it: 'You may be tricked into thinking that your own special trade or your own business will be helped by protective trade laws, but it stands to reason that such laws must in the long run keep away wealth from the country, reduce the value of our trade, and lower the general conditions of life on this island.'"
"What do you think of that, Watson?" cried Holmes cheerfully, rubbing his hands together. "Don't you agree it is a fine piece of writing?"
Dr. Mortimer stared at Holmes with professional curiosity, while Sir Henry turned his puzzled dark eyes toward me.
"I don't know much about trade laws and things like that," said Sir Henry, "but it feels to me like we've wandered off the trail of that letter."
"On the contrary, Sir Henry, we are right on the trail. Watson knows my methods better than you do, yet I see even he hasn't caught the connection."
"No, I admit I see none at all."
"And yet, my dear Watson, the two are so closely tied that one was taken straight out of the other. 'You,' 'your,' 'your,' 'life,' 'reason,' 'value,' 'keep away,' 'from the.' Now do you see where those words came from?"
"By thunder, you're right! Well, if that isn't smart!" cried Sir Henry.
"And if any doubt remained, look closely—'keep away' was cut out in one piece, and 'from the' was cut out in one piece too."
"Well, look at that—so they were!"
"Really, Mr. Holmes, this goes beyond anything I could have imagined," said Dr. Mortimer in amazement. "Anyone might guess the words came from a newspaper, but naming the exact paper and even the exact page is one of the most remarkable things I have ever seen. How did you do it?"
"I suppose, Doctor, you could tell an ancient skull from a modern one?"
"Of course."
"But how?"
"Because skulls are my special study. The differences are plain to see—the ridge above the eyes, the angle of the face, the curve of the jaw—"
"Well, printed type is my special study, and the differences are just as plain to me. To my eyes, the clean, well-spaced print of a *Times* opinion piece looks as different from the sloppy print of a cheap evening paper as an ancient skull looks from a modern one to yours. Knowing newspaper print is one of the first skills an investigator learns—though I admit that once, when I was very young, I confused two provincial papers. Still, a *Times* article has a look all its own, and those words could have come from nowhere else. Since the letter was mailed yesterday, yesterday's issue was the obvious place to look."
"So far as I follow you, Mr. Holmes," said Sir Henry, "someone cut out this message with a pair of scissors—"
"Nail scissors," said Holmes. "You can tell the blades were very short, because whoever cut it had to make two snips to cut out 'keep away.'"
"Right. Someone cut out the words with short-bladed scissors and stuck them down with paste—"
"Gum," said Holmes.
"With gum onto the paper. But why did they write the word 'moor' in ink?"
"Because they couldn't find it in print. All the other words are common and appear in almost any issue, while 'moor' is much rarer."
"Of course—that explains it. Have you read anything else from this message, Mr. Holmes?"
"There are several clues here, even though someone tried very hard to hide them all. Notice how the address is written in rough block letters. Yet the *Times* is a paper seldom read except by educated people. So the letter was almost certainly made by an educated person pretending to be uneducated—and hiding their handwriting suggests that their writing is known to you, or might soon become known to you. Again, look at the line of words. They aren't glued straight; some sit much higher than others. 'Life,' for instance, is quite out of line. That shows either carelessness or hurry and nervous excitement. On a matter this serious, carelessness is unlikely, so the sender was in a hurry. Why hurry, when any letter mailed before morning would reach you before you left the hotel? Were they afraid someone might walk in and catch them—and if so, who?"
"Now we are moving into guesswork," said Dr. Mortimer.
"Call it weighing probabilities and choosing the most likely explanation," said Holmes. "It is the scientific use of the imagination, and we always start from solid facts. You might think it is just a guess, yet I am almost certain that this address was written in a hotel."
"How on earth can you know that?"
"Look closely at the letters. Both the pen and the ink gave the writer trouble. The pen spluttered twice inside a single word and ran dry three times during that short address, proving the ink bottle was nearly empty. Private pens and ink bottles are rarely left in such a state, and both together almost never happen at home. In a hotel writing room, however, it is rare to find anything better. Yes, I wouldn't hesitate to say that if we searched the wastebaskets of the hotels around Charing Cross until we found the cut page of the *Times*, we could put our hands straight on the person who sent this strange warning. Wait—what is this?"
Holmes was holding the sheet of paper only an inch or two from his eyes, studying it intently.
"Well?" I asked.
"Nothing," he said, tossing it down on the table. "It is just a plain half-sheet of paper, without even a watermark. I think we have learned all we can from this curious letter. Now, Sir Henry, has anything else unusual happened since you arrived in London?"
"No, Mr. Holmes, I don't think so."
"You haven't noticed anyone watching or following you?"
"I feel as if I've walked straight into a cheap adventure novel," said Sir Henry. "Why on earth would anyone watch or follow me?"
"We are coming to that. Have you nothing else at all to tell us before we get into it?"
"Well, that depends on what you think is worth telling."
"I think anything outside the ordinary routine of daily life is well worth telling."
Sir Henry smiled. "I don't know much about English life yet, since I've spent nearly all my time in the United States and Canada. Still, I hope losing one of your boots isn't part of the ordinary routine over here."
"You lost one of your boots?"
"My dear sir," cried Dr. Mortimer, "you only misplaced it! You'll find it when you get back to the hotel. Why trouble Mr. Holmes with little things like that?"
"Well, he asked for anything outside the ordinary routine."
"Quite right," said Holmes, "no matter how silly it sounds. You lost one of your boots, you say?"
"Misplaced it, anyway. I put both boots outside my door last night, and this morning only one was there. I couldn't get a straight answer out of the man who cleans them. Worse still, I only bought the pair yesterday evening in the Strand, and I've never even worn them."
"If you never wore them, why did you leave them out to be cleaned?"
"They were new brown boots and hadn't been polished yet. That's why I set them outside."
"So right after arriving in London yesterday, you went out and bought a pair of boots?"
"I did quite a bit of shopping. Dr. Mortimer here came around with me. After all, if I'm going to be the landowner down there, I ought to dress properly—I've grown a bit casual out West. Among other things, I bought those brown boots, and one of them vanished before I ever put them on."
"It seems a remarkably useless thing to steal," said Holmes. "I have to agree with Dr. Mortimer—the missing boot will probably turn up soon."
"And now, gentlemen," said Sir Henry firmly, "I've talked quite enough about the little I know. It is time you kept your promise and told me clearly what this is all about."
"A very fair request," answered Holmes. "Dr. Mortimer, you couldn't do better than to tell your story just as you told it to us."
Dr. Mortimer pulled his papers from his pocket and laid out the entire case as he had the morning before—the old legend of 1742, the newspaper account of Sir Charles's death in May, and the giant footprints he had seen near the body in the yew alley. Sir Henry listened with intense focus, breaking in only now and then with a low exclamation of surprise.
"Well, this is quite an inheritance I've stepped into," he said when the story ended. "Of course, I've heard about the hound since I was in the nursery. It's the family's favorite ghost story, though I never thought of taking it seriously before. As for my uncle's death—my head is spinning, and I can't make sense of it yet. Even you gentlemen don't seem sure whether this is work for the police or for a priest."
"Exactly," said Holmes.
"And now there's this letter sent to my hotel. I suppose that fits into the puzzle somehow."
"It shows someone knows more than we do about what is happening on the moor," said Dr. Mortimer.
"And also," added Holmes, "that someone wishes you well—or at least wants to warn you of danger."
"Or else they want to frighten me away for reasons of their own," said Sir Henry.
"That is possible too, of course. I am very grateful to you, Dr. Mortimer, for bringing me a case with so many interesting angles. The practical question we must decide right now, Sir Henry, is whether you ought to go to Baskerville Hall or not."
"Why shouldn't I go?"
"Because there seems to be danger."
"Danger from this family devil, or danger from human beings?"
"That is what we still have to discover."
"Whichever it is, my mind is made up. There is no devil in hell, Mr. Holmes, and there is no man upon earth who can prevent me from going to the home of my own people, and you may take that to be my final answer."
His dark eyebrows drew together and his face flushed deep red as he spoke. Clearly the fierce temper of the Baskervilles was still alive in this last member of the family.
"For the moment," he went on, "I've barely had time to think over everything you've told me. That's a lot for one man to take in at a single sitting. I'd like a quiet hour alone to clear my head. Look here, Mr. Holmes, it's half-past eleven now, and I'm going straight back to my hotel. Why don't you and Dr. Watson join us for lunch at two? By then I'll be able to tell you more clearly how I see things."
"Does that suit you, Watson?"
"Perfectly."
"Then expect us at two. Shall I send for a cab?"
"No, I'd rather walk. All this has stirred me up a bit."
"I'll gladly walk with you," said Dr. Mortimer.
"Then we'll see you at two o'clock. Goodbye until then!"
We heard their footsteps go down the stairs and the front door bang shut. In an instant Holmes changed from a quiet thinker into a man of action.
"Your hat and boots, Watson, quick! Not a second to lose!"
He dashed into his bedroom in his dressing gown and hurried out seconds later wearing a coat. Together we raced down the stairs and out into the street. Dr. Mortimer and Sir Henry were still in sight about two hundred yards ahead, walking toward Oxford Street.
"Should I run ahead and stop them?"
"Not for the world, my dear Watson. Your company is quite enough for me, if you don't mind mine. Our friends are right—it really is a lovely morning for a walk."
Holmes quickened his steps until we had cut the distance between us and them in half. Keeping about a hundred yards back, we followed them into Oxford Street and then down Regent Street. Once, the two men ahead stopped to look into a shop window, and Holmes stopped too. A moment later he gave a quiet cry of satisfaction. Following his sharp gaze, I saw a cab on the far side of the street, which had stopped when our friends stopped, begin moving slowly forward again.
"There is our man, Watson! Come on—let's get a good look at him, if nothing else."
Just then I saw a thick black beard and a pair of sharp eyes looking out at us through the side window of the cab. Instantly the little roof hatch snapped open, someone shouted an order to the driver, and the cab shot forward down Regent Street at full speed. Holmes scanned the street for another cab, but not a single empty one was in sight. He dashed wildly into the stream of traffic on foot, yet the cab already had too big a lead and vanished from view.
"Look at that!" Holmes muttered bitterly, stepping back onto the sidewalk breathless and pale with anger. "Was there ever worse luck—or worse management? Watson, Watson, if you are an honest man you will record this also and set it against my successes!"
"Who was he?"
"I have no idea."
"A spy?"
"Obviously Sir Henry has been watched very closely since reaching London. How else could anyone learn so fast that he had chosen the Northumberland Hotel? If they followed him yesterday, I guessed they would follow him today too. You may have noticed I strolled over to the window twice while Dr. Mortimer was reading his legend."
"Yes, I remember."
"I was looking for anyone loitering in the street, and saw nobody. We are dealing with a clever opponent, Watson. This business goes very deep. Whether the force behind it means good or harm, I can feel steady power and careful planning. When our friends left, I followed at once to spot their hidden watcher. He was smart enough not to go on foot—he hired a cab so he could drift behind them or pass them without drawing notice, and stay ready if they took a cab themselves. That plan has one clear weakness, however."
"It puts him in the cab driver's hands."
"Exactly."
"What a shame we didn't catch the cab's number!"
"My dear Watson, clumsy as I was, surely you don't think I forgot to take the number? Number 2704 is our cab—though that doesn't help us at this exact second."
"I don't see what more you could have done."
"When I spotted the cab, I should have turned straight around and walked the other way. Then I could have calmly hired another cab to follow it at a safe distance—or better yet, driven straight to the Northumberland Hotel and waited there. Once our unknown friend followed Sir Henry back to his hotel, we could have played his own game against him and seen where he went afterward. Instead, my foolish eagerness warned a very sharp opponent, and we gave ourselves away and lost him."
We had been strolling slowly down Regent Street while we talked, and Dr. Mortimer and Sir Henry had long since disappeared ahead of us.
"There's no point following them now," said Holmes. "The watcher is gone and won't come back today. Let's see what cards we still hold and play them firmly. Could you swear to that man's face in court?"
"I could only swear to his beard."
"And so could I—which means it was almost certainly a false one. A clever man on such delicate business has no reason to wear a big beard except to hide his face. Step inside here, Watson!"
Holmes turned into a district messenger office, where the manager welcomed him warmly.
"Ah, Wilson, I see you still remember the little affair where I had the luck to assist you?"
"Indeed I do, sir. You saved my good name, and maybe my life."
"You exaggerate, my good man. If I remember rightly, you had a boy named Cartwright here who showed real promise during that case."
"Yes, sir, he is still with us."
"Would you call him in? Thank you. And could you change this five-pound note into shillings?"
A boy of fourteen with a bright, sharp face answered the bell and stood looking at the famous detective with open admiration.
"Let me see the hotel directory," said Holmes. "Thank you. Now, Cartwright, here are the names of twenty-three hotels, all within walking distance of Charing Cross. Do you see?"
"Yes, sir."
"You will visit every single one of them."
"Yes, sir."
"At each hotel, start by giving the outside porter one shilling. Here are twenty-three shillings."
"Yes, sir."
"Tell him you need to check yesterday's waste paper because an important telegram went missing, and you are trying to find it. Clear?"
"Yes, sir."
"What you are really looking for is the middle page of yesterday's *Times* with holes cut out of it by scissors. Here is yesterday's *Times*. This is the page. You would recognize it easily, wouldn't you?"
"Yes, sir."
"In each hotel, the outside porter will fetch the hall porter. Give him one shilling as well—here are another twenty-three shillings. In maybe twenty out of the twenty-three hotels, they'll tell you yesterday's paper has already been burned or carted off. In the other three, they'll show you a pile of paper, and you'll search through it for that *Times* page. The chances are heavily against your finding it, of course. Here are ten extra shillings in case anything unexpected comes up. Send me a telegram at Baker Street before evening to report what you find. Now, Watson, all we have left to do is send a telegram to learn who drives cab number 2704, and then drop into a Bond Street art gallery to pass the time until lunch at the hotel."