Up to now I have been able to copy the reports I sent to Sherlock Holmes during my first days in Devon. From this point on, however, I must rely on my own memory, helped by the diary I kept at the time. A few pages from that diary will carry the story forward into events I can never forget. I begin, then, on the morning after our failed chase of the convict on the moor.
*October 16*
It is a gray, foggy day with a cold drizzle of rain. Thick clouds press down around the Hall, lifting only now and then to reveal the lonely hills, thin silver streams running down their slopes, and distant boulders shining wetly in the pale light. It is gloomy outside and in. Sir Henry is in a dark mood after last night's shock. I feel a heavy weight on my own heart too—a sense of unseen danger hanging close around us, all the worse because I cannot give it a name.
And have I not good reason to feel this way? Look at the long chain of events pointing toward some evil power at work here. Sir Charles's death matched every detail of the family legend. Country people repeatedly report seeing a strange creature out on the moor. Twice with my own ears I have heard a sound like the distant howling of a hound. It is impossible—unthinkable—that something outside the laws of nature truly walks out there. A ghostly hound that leaves real footprints in gravel and fills the night with howls makes no sense at all. Stapleton and Mortimer may play along with such ideas, yet if I have one gift, it is common sense, and nothing will ever make me believe in a phantom beast with fire shooting from its eyes. Holmes would laugh at such stories, and I am here to represent him.
Still, facts are facts, and I *have* heard that cry twice. Suppose a real, enormous hound is actually loose on the moor—that would explain a great deal. Yet where could a huge hound hide? Who feeds it? Where did it come from, and why does nobody ever see it in daylight? I must admit the natural explanation raises almost as many questions as the supernatural one.
And quite apart from the hound, there is human plotting as well—the bearded stranger in the London cab, and the warning letter sent to Sir Henry. That much was real, though it could be the work of a hidden friend just as easily as an enemy. Where is that person now? Did he stay in London, or follow us down to Devon? Could he—could he possibly be the tall, thin man I saw standing on the tor?
I caught only one glance at him, yet there are some things I know for sure. He is nobody I have met around here, and by now I have met all the neighbors. He was far taller than Stapleton and far thinner than Frankland. Barrymore was back at the Hall, so it could not have been him. That means a stranger is still following us here, just as someone followed us in London. We have never shaken him off. If I could only lay hands on that man, we might finally reach the end of this dark business. From this moment on, finding him must be my single goal.
My first thought was to share my plan with Sir Henry. On second thought, it is wiser to work quietly and say nothing to anyone. His nerves were badly shaken by that cry on the moor, and he is silent and lost in thought. I will not add to his worries; instead, I will take my own steps quietly.
We had a small scene this morning after breakfast. Barrymore asked for a private word with Sir Henry in his study. Sitting in the billiard room, I heard raised voices more than once and had a fair idea what they were arguing about. At last Sir Henry opened the door and called me in.
"Barrymore has a complaint," he said. "He thinks it was unfair of us to hunt down his brother-in-law after he told us the secret."
The butler stood very pale, yet calm and respectful, in front of us.
"I may have spoken too strongly, sir," he said, "and if so, I beg your pardon. Still, I was very surprised when I heard you two gentlemen come back in the middle of the night and learned you had been chasing Selden. The poor man has enough against him without my putting new hunters on his trail."
"If you had trusted us freely, it would be different," said Sir Henry. "You only told us—or rather, your wife told us—when we caught you red-handed and left you no choice."
"I didn't think you would use it against us, Sir Henry—indeed I didn't."
"The man is a public danger. Lonely houses sit scattered all over this moor, and he looks like a man who would stop at nothing. One glance at his face tells you that. Think of Mr. Stapleton's house, with nobody but himself to protect it. No one is safe until Selden is locked back behind bars."
"He won't break into any house, sir. I give you my word on that. And he will never trouble anyone in this country again. I assure you, Sir Henry, that within a few days everything will be ready and he will be on a ship bound for South America. For God's sake, sir, I beg you not to tell the police he is still on the moor! They have given up searching here, and he can lie quiet until his ship sails. You can't turn him in without getting my wife and me into serious trouble. Please, sir, say nothing to the police."
"What do you say, Watson?" Sir Henry asked.
I shrugged. "If he leaves the country for good, it saves the taxpayers plenty of money."
"What if he attacks someone before he goes?"
"He would never do anything so foolish, sir. We have given him all the food and supplies he needs. Committing a crime now would tell the police exactly where he is hiding."
"That is true," said Sir Henry. "Well, Barrymore—"
"God bless you, sir, and thank you from the bottom of my heart! It would have killed my poor wife if he had been caught again."
"I suppose we are breaking the law by helping a wanted criminal, Watson. Still, after everything we have heard, I don't have the heart to turn him in, so let that be the end of it. All right, Barrymore, you may go."
Stammering a few broken words of thanks, the butler turned toward the door—then paused and walked back.
"You have been so good to us, sir, that I want to do something for you in return," he said. "I know a fact, Sir Henry, and perhaps I ought to have told it sooner, though I only learned it long after the inquest. I haven't breathed a word of it to another living soul. It is about Sir Charles's death."
Sir Henry and I both jumped to our feet. "Do you know how he died?"
"No, sir, not that."
"What, then?"
"I know why he was waiting by the gate at that hour. He went there to meet a woman."
"To meet a woman? Sir Charles?"
"Yes, sir."
"Who was she?"
"I can't give you her name, sir, only her initials. Her initials were L. L."
"How do you know this, Barrymore?"
"Well, Sir Henry, your uncle received a letter that morning. Usually he got dozens of letters, for he was an important man with a generous heart, and anyone in trouble felt free to write to him. That morning, however, only this single letter arrived, which is why I happened to notice it. It came from Coombe Tracey, and the address was written in a woman's hand."
"Go on."
"Well, sir, I thought nothing more about it, and I never would have, if not for my wife. Just a few weeks ago she finally cleaned out Sir Charles's study—nobody had touched it since his death—and she found the ashes of a burned letter at the back of the fireplace. Almost all of it had turned to black dust, except one small strip at the bottom of a page that still held together. You could still read the gray writing against the black ash. It seemed to be a note added at the end, and it read: 'Please, please, as you are a gentleman, burn this letter, and be at the gate by ten o'clock.' Beneath it were the initials L. L."
"Do you still have that piece of paper?"
"No, sir, it crumbled to dust the moment we touched it."
"Did Sir Charles ever get other letters in that same handwriting?"
"I never paid special attention to his mail, sir. I only noticed this one because it came alone."
"And you have no idea who L. L. is?"
"No, sir, no more than you do. Still, I imagine if we could find that lady, we would learn a great deal more about Sir Charles's death."
"I don't understand, Barrymore, how you could hide something so important!"
"Well, sir, our own troubles began right afterward. Besides, my wife and I were very fond of Sir Charles after everything he had done for us. Digging into his private life couldn't bring him back, and it is always wise to tread carefully when a lady is involved. Even the best of men—"
"You worried it might hurt his good name?"
"I thought no good could come of it, sir. Now that you have shown us such kindness, though, I felt it would be unfair not to tell you everything I know."
"Very well, Barrymore. You may go."
When the butler left the room, Sir Henry turned to me. "Well, Watson, what do you make of this new light?"
"It seems to leave things even darker than before."
"I agree. Still, if we can trace L. L., it might explain the whole mystery. At least we know there is a living person who knows the facts, if we can only reach her. What should we do next?"
"Write to Holmes about it at once. This is the exact kind of clue he has been looking for. I will be very surprised if it doesn't bring him down here immediately."
I went straight to my room and wrote a full letter to Holmes describing our talk with Barrymore. He must be terribly busy in London right now, for his recent notes from Baker Street have been short and rare, with no comments on my reports and barely a word about our case. That blackmail investigation must be taking all his time. Even so, this fresh clue is bound to catch his attention and pull him back into our mystery. How I wish he were here!
*October 17*
Rain poured down all day today, rustling through the ivy and dripping steadily from the roof. My thoughts kept turning to Selden, crouching somewhere out on the cold, bare, shelterless moor. Poor devil—whatever crimes he has committed, he is paying hard for them now. Then I thought of that other man—the bearded face in the cab, the dark figure against the moon. Was this unseen watcher out in the storm too?
Late in the afternoon I pulled on my raincoat and walked far out onto the soaked moor, my mind full of dark thoughts as wind and rain beat against my face. God help anyone who steps into the great Grimpen Mire in weather like this, for even the high, firm ground is turning to soft mud. I found the Black Tor—the rocky hilltop where I had seen the lonely watcher—and climbed to its top to look across the dreary hills. Sheets of rain swept over the brown grass, and heavy gray clouds hung low, trailing ragged mist down the sides of the hills. Far off to the left, half hidden in fog, the two thin towers of Baskerville Hall rose above the trees. Aside from those towers, the only signs of human hands in that empty land were the prehistoric stone huts scattered across the hillsides. Not a single trace remained of the silent stranger who had stood on this rock two nights before.
On my walk back, Dr. Mortimer overtook me, driving his small cart down a rough moor track from Foulmire farm. He has been wonderfully attentive, calling at the Hall almost every day to check on us, and he insisted I climb in for a ride home. I found him deeply upset because his little spaniel had wandered off onto the moor and vanished. I tried to comfort him as best I could, though I silently pictured that poor pony sinking into the Grimpen Mire and doubted he would ever see his little dog again.
"By the way, Mortimer," I said as we bounced along the stony track, "I suppose there are very few people living within driving distance whom you don't know?"
"Hardly anyone, I think."
"Could you tell me the name of any woman whose initials are L. L.?"
He thought for a minute or two.
"No," he said. "There are a few traveling people and farm workers I couldn't answer for, of course, but among the local farmers or wealthier families, nobody has those initials. Wait a second, though," he added after a pause. "There is Laura Lyons—her initials are L. L.—though she lives in Coombe Tracey."
"Who is she?" I asked.
"She is Frankland's daughter."
"What! Old Frankland, the man who loves lawsuits?"
"The very same. She married an artist named Lyons who came to paint on the moor. He turned out to be a cruel, dishonest man and walked out on her—though from what I hear, the blame wasn't entirely on one side. Her father refused to have anything more to do with her because she married without his permission, and perhaps for one or two other reasons as well. Between the stubborn old father and the worthless young husband, the poor woman had a terrible time."
"How does she support herself?"
"Old Frankland gives her nothing, and his own money all goes on lawsuits anyway. Whatever mistakes she made, nobody wanted to see her sink completely. People here heard her story and chipped in to help her earn an honest living. Stapleton helped, Sir Charles helped, and I gave a small sum myself. We set her up in a typing business."
Mortimer naturally asked why I wanted to know about her, but I answered without giving anything away. There is no reason to share our secrets with anyone right now. Tomorrow morning I will make my way to Coombe Tracey, and if I can speak to Mrs. Laura Lyons, we may take a huge step toward solving one piece of this puzzle. I must be growing cleverer at keeping secrets, for when Mortimer started asking too many awkward questions, I casually asked him what type of skull old Frankland had—and for the rest of the drive I heard about nothing except skulls! Living for years with Sherlock Holmes has clearly taught me a trick or two.
I have just one more event to set down on this stormy, gloomy day, and it may prove to be the most important card in my hand yet.
Dr. Mortimer stayed for dinner and played cards with Sir Henry afterward. When Barrymore brought my coffee into the library, I took the opportunity to ask him a few quiet questions.
"Well," I said, "has your relative left the moor yet, or is he still hiding out there?"
"I don't know, sir. I pray to heaven he is gone, for he has brought nothing but trouble here! I haven't seen any sign of him since I last left food out three days ago."
"Did you see him then?"
"No, sir, though the food was gone when I walked back that way."
"So he was definitely still there."
"You would think so, sir—unless the other man took it."
I froze with my coffee cup halfway to my lips and stared at Barrymore.
"You know there is *another* man out there?"
"Yes, sir. There is another man hiding on the moor."
"Have you seen him?"
"No, sir."
"Then how do you know about him?"
"Selden told me about him a week or more ago, sir. He is in hiding too, though he isn't a convict, as far as Selden could tell. I don't like it, Dr. Watson—I tell you straight, sir, I don't like it at all."
He spoke with sudden, urgent fear.
"Listen to me, Barrymore," I said. "I care about nothing here except Sir Henry's safety. That is the only reason I came. Tell me honestly—what frightens you so much?"
Barrymore paused a moment, as if regretting his outburst or searching for the right words.
"It is everything going on around us, sir," he burst out, waving a hand toward the rain-streaked window facing the moor. "There is foul play somewhere, and dark evil brewing—I would swear to it! Nothing would make me happier than seeing Sir Henry safely back on the train to London!"
"What exactly are you afraid of?"
"Look at Sir Charles's death, sir! That was bad enough, no matter what the inquest decided. Look at those awful cries on the moor at night—not a man in this county would cross it after dark for any sum of money. And now look at this stranger hiding out there, watching and waiting! What is he waiting for? What does it all mean? It means no good to anyone with the name Baskerville, and I will be glad to walk away from this house the day Sir Henry's new servants arrive."
"Tell me about this stranger," I urged. "What else did Selden say? Did he find out where the man hides, or what he is doing?"
"He spotted him once or twice, though the man is careful and keeps to himself. At first Selden thought he was a policeman, but soon saw he had some private business of his own. A gentleman of sorts, by the look of him, though Selden couldn't guess what he was up to."
"And where did he say this man lives?"
"Among the old ruins on the hillside—the stone huts where the ancient people used to live."
"How does he get his food?"
"Selden found out he has a boy working for him who brings whatever he needs. Probably goes into Coombe Tracey for supplies."
"Thank you, Barrymore. We will talk more about this later."
After the butler left, I walked over to the dark window and stared through the rain-blurred glass at the racing clouds and swaying trees. It is a wild night even inside these thick walls—what must it be like out in a crumbling stone hut on the open moor? What deep hatred or desperate purpose drives a man to hide in a place like that in weather like this?
There, inside that stone hut on the moor, lies the dark heart of the mystery that has troubled me for so long. I swear that before another day ends, I will do everything in my power to uncover who that man is—and what he wants with Sir Henry.